Welcome to Milano Pizza Shop
At Milano Pizza Shop, located in the heart of New York City, we celebrate over two decades of authentic Italian flavors. Our story is rooted in tradition, offering classic favorites like our mouthwatering cheese pizza slices and homemade calzones—all at wallet-friendly prices. The aroma of our kitchen evokes nostalgia, as loyal patrons reminisce about their cherished memories of great meals shared here. From the crispy chicken cutlet pizza to the satisfying eggplant Parmesan, every dish is crafted with love and care. Cash-only transactions add a nostalgic touch to your visit, ensuring a genuine, old-school NYC experience. Welcome to your new favorite pizza haven!
-
2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, United States Hotline: +1 212-996-5141
Welcome to Milano Pizza Shop, a beloved beacon of authentic New York pizza culture nestled on the vibrant 2nd Avenue. This local gem has been satisfying cravings for two decades, attracting pizza lovers with its delicious offerings and welcoming atmosphere. What truly sets Milano apart is its commitment to quality and tradition, providing not just food, but a slice of nostalgia for many.
At Milano Pizza Shop, the menu boasts a delightful array of choices. Pizza enthusiasts can indulge in their classic Regular Cheese Pizza for just $12.00, or opt for an adventurous creation by building their own. The two-choice and half-and-half pizzas allow diners to explore different flavors without compromise. Prices are reasonable, making it easy to satisfy cravings without breaking the bank.
- Spinach Roll - $6.00
- Cheese Calzone - $6.00
- Meat Calzone - $6.00
- Garlic Knots - $1.00
- Chicken Roll - $6.00
- Beef Patty - $2.50
Additionally, Milano takes pride in its selection of salads, offering fresh, wholesome options like the S hrimp Salad and the popular Antipasto Salad. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring that every bite is bursting with flavor.
Customer reviews echo a sentiment of loyalty and love for this eatery. Patrons praise the chicken slice, described as "filling, tasty, and crispy," while others reminisce about the shop’s enduring legacy and commitment to quality. One reviewer highlights it as "the best on Manhattan's East Side, maybe all of NYC," a bold claim that speaks to its reputation among locals.
Beyond the food, Milano Pizza Shop creates an atmosphere where patrons feel at home. The friendly staff provide excellent service, ensuring that every visit is pleasant. Plus, the cash-only policy keeps things straightforward, reminding us of an old-school charm that many appreciate.
So, if you find yourself in the neighborhood, stop by Milano Pizza Shop. Treat yourself to a slice of their delightful pizza or a hearty calzone, and experience the magic that has kept New Yorkers coming back for more for years. You may just find your new favorite spot!
Delicious pizza and one of the few places you can just call and receive delivery paying cash. Such a hidden gem.
I’ve been coming here for about 20years and he food is still amazing, please support this business, amazing, whatever u get u won’t be disappointed.
Can I get a slice of goodness went to my old pizza spot last week and I had to leave a review the slice just melts while u enjoy each view tbay hits your taste buds
I’ve been a loyal customer of Milano's since way back when they even accepted food stamps in the old booklet days. Their pizza is unmatched—the best on Manhattan’s East Side, maybe all of NYC. Highly recommend!
Wow that Pizza Shop has been there for ever , great place to eat for me especially the Eggplant Parmesan With baked Ziti. And My husband Always Has the Meatball Hero. Great Place To Eat We love it
Made me feel like a kid again. The pizza is definitely OLD SCHOOL NYC
The Chicken Slice. This review is on my go-to slice at this location. Their chicken slice is like no other. It’s filling, tasty, crispy, and just enough of the tomato sauce and cheese proportion IMO. You can pick out the chicken and eat them as you go because it does make the slice a bit heavier so its good to take the pieces every other bite. Then the crust, oh my, its not super doughy, but it’s fluffy . Anyways, definitely a slice to try here is their chicken slice. The others are okay. Oh, this is a CASH ONLY location so make sure you have at least a 10 to eat well. There’s an ATM across 2nd avenue inside of 7 Eleven in case you don’t have any cash.
Amazing Spot to grab a Slice of a Nice Sandwich . Fantastic customer service.